Twins sign veteran SS Erick Aybar to minor league contract

Twins sign veteran SS Erick Aybar to minor league contract

FORT MYERS, Fla. (AP) — The Minnesota Twins have signed 12-year veteran shortstop Erick Aybar to a minor league contract with an invitation to major league spring training.

The Twins announced the deal on Saturday, when Aybar was expected to report to camp. Aybar made his debut with the Los Angeles Angels in 2006 and was their everyday shortstop for seven seasons. He won a Gold Glove award in 2011 and made the All-Star team in 2014. He played last year for the San Diego Padres, batting .234 with 11 stolen bases in 333 at-bats.

The Twins have plenty of middle infield depth behind second baseman Brian Dozier and shortstop Jorge Polanco with versatile backups Eduardo Escobar and Ehire Adrianza, so Aybar will be a long shot to make the team.

For more AP baseball coverage:

Twins sign Erick Aybar to minor-league deal

Twins sign Erick Aybar to minor-league deal

The Twins are signing Erick Aybar to a minor league deal, according to LaVelle E. Neal III of the Star Tribune.

The 12-year veteran is expecting to compete for an infield job in the Twins infield that includes Jorge Polanco, Brian Dozier, and Eduardo Escobar, among others. The 34-year-old Aybar hit .234/.300/.348 with seven homers, 22 RBIs, 15 doubles, and one triple in 108 games in San Diego last season.

Aybar has been known for being a light-handed versatile infielder, and on a relatively young Minnesota roster, he may struggle to make the roster. Still, with the ability to play shortstop, second base, and third, he will likely see some time on the big league roster at some point during the 2018 season. He may also have an opportunity to open the season on the big league roster in the event that Miguel Sano ends up facing discipline from the MLB on resulting from an assault charge that the league is investigating.

Twins hopeful of more progress for ace-in-training Berrios

Twins hopeful of more progress for ace-in-training Berrios

FILE – In this Monday, Sept. 4, 2017 file photo, Minnesota Twins’ Jose Berrios pitches to the Tampa Bay Rays during the first inning of a baseball game in St. Petersburg, Fla. Jose Berrios made major strides for the Minnesota Twins last season after a rough rookie year. Now comes the next step, establishing himself as a truce ace of the rotation. (AP Photo/Chris O’Meara, File)

FORT MYERS, Fla. (AP) — With his sharp-breaking curveball, a fastball averaging 94 mph and the fitness of an elite athlete, Jose Berrios has every reason to be confident on the mound.

Last season, he finally was.

From the day he was drafted out of Puerto Rico by the Minnesota Twins with the 32nd overall pick in 2012, Berrios has been one of the organization’s best pitching prospects. He thrived at every level of the minors, and once he made it to Minnesota in 2016 there were no concerns about him being able to adapt to major league hitters and entrench himself in the rotation for years to come.

His debut was quite the dud, though, with an unsightly 8.02 ERA over 14 starts. He gave up 12 home runs and 35 walks in 58 1/3 innings. The missing ingredient, then, was self-assurance.

”Sometimes when things were going wrong,” Berrios said, searching for a second to arrive at the right word in English, ”I got discouraged.”

Hard to figure for someone who’s so talented – but everyone is human.

”And he’s a very humble guy, so he’s not going to go out and tell you how great his stuff is. I think that’s a benefit for him because he’s constantly striving to get better and not satisfied with his stuff. I think that’s what’s going to make him good for the length of his career at this level,” said catcher Jason Castro, who played a significant part in helping Berrios make some mechanical and mental adjustments in 2017.

”His stuff is always going to play because it’s just that good, but getting him to stay within himself and be consistent and not try to overthrow,” Castro said. ”There were some things we identified that might help him out. He worked through it and did a heck of a job for us.”

Last season was a large step forward for Berrios. Opponents batted .239 against him, down from .310 as a rookie. His walks-per-nine-innings rate was reduced from 5.4 to 3.0.

The tone for improvement was set in his first start of the year on May 13 after being recalled from Triple-A Rochester, when Berrios gave up just two hits and one run in 7 2/3 innings at Cleveland. He finished 14-8 with a 3.89 ERA.

”I learned if I believe in myself and be positive all the time, I’ll be successful in the game because God gives me the ability to play the sport and I work every day hard,” said Berrios, who has three children with his wife, all of them under 4 years old.

That hard work has been well documented on social media, where Berrios will frequently post videos of his strenuous workouts throughout the offseason. The Twins don’t want him to overdo it, of course, but Berrios said that’s not a concern.

”During the offseason, I don’t play baseball. I’m just working out and preparing myself to get ready,” he said. ”During the season, I come down a little bit.”

The 23-year-old right-hander has more progress to make to become the legitimate front-of-the-rotation pitcher the Twins have envisioned, and the finger injury that’s expected to keep Ervin Santana out for much of April will give Berrios an opportunity to step forward. Perhaps even on the mound on opening day.

”That would mean a lot. Every good pitcher wants to be there on the first day, but right now we prepare ourselves to pitch every five days,” Berrios said.

Minnesota manager Paul Molitor has yet to declare his starter for the earlier-than-usual opener on March 29 at Baltimore. He also has understandably yet to declare his full faith in Berrios as that ace the Twins have mostly been missing since Johan Santana was traded 10 years ago.

”I think we all are hopeful he’s going to be that kind of guy. I always caution people not to jump too far too fast on people that young,” Molitor said. ”He’s got experience, but it’s not a ton. We’re expecting growth. How far he takes that from the opening part of the season until the end, it’s 162 games away.”

For more AP baseball coverage:

Twins had a great offseason that nobody's talking about

Twins had a great offseason that nobody's talking about

If a larger-market playoff team had an offseason as successful as the Minnesota Twins just had, people would be talking about it way more.

After finishing fourth in the American League in runs scored and OPS and third in on-base percentage, Minnesota not only retained its young starting lineup that just reached the postseason as the second wild card, but vastly improved its pitching staff with shrewd signings and trades for established veterans to complement the core. With Detroit and Kansas City entering rebuilding phases and Chicago’s well underway, Minnesota is in position to benefit from a power vacuum in the AL Central and improve on its 85-77 record from 2017.

RIVERA: Wait a second. Did the Mets win the offseason?

The Twins’ bullpen posted a 4.40 ERA last season, the fourth highest in the AL, while striking out just 7.66 batters per nine innings, the second lowest rate in the majors, ahead of only Baltimore. The six teams with the highest strikeout rates among relievers last season, per Fangraphs — the Yankees, Astros, Dodgers, Indians, Cubs and Red Sox — all made the playoffs. So Minnesota overhauled its bullpen by signing Fernando Rodney (10.57 K/9 last season) from Arizona, Addison Reed (9.00 K/9 with a 2.84 ERA) from Boston and Zach Duke, who struck out 10.03 batters per nine innings in 2016 before an injury-riddled 2017 with St. Louis.

Minnesota’s rotation had its issues last season as well, throwing 869 2/3 innings, the fourth fewest in the AL Twins starters struck out just 7.08 batters per nine innings, the fourth fewest in the league and fifth fewest in baseball, though attacking the strike zone and pitching to contact has long been their strategy. Regardless, the Twins finished 10th in the AL in rotation ERA, a number that must get better if they want to build on their 2017 success.  

Over the weekend, the Twins acquired a similar pitch-to-contact strike zone attacker from Tampa Bay in Jake Odorizzi, who posted a career worst 4.14 ERA last season and won 10 games, a win total which should increase with better run support. The Rays scored just 4.21 runs per Odorizzi start last season, the eighth lowest mark among AL starters with the least 140 innings pitched, per ESPN.

Odorizzi will ultimately slot into the third spot in Minnesota’s rotation behind Jose Berrios, who won 14 games with a 3.89 ERA in his Age 23 season, and Ervin Santana, who had a spectacular 2017 — with 16 wins and a 3.22 ERA — but is expected to be out until at least May after finger surgery. In addition to Kyle Gibson, 24-year-old lefty Adalberto Mejia and Phil Hughes — who’s still recovering from thoracic outlet surgery that he underwent in August — Minnesota signed veterans Anibal Sanchez and Michael Pineda (expected to miss the season after Tommy John surgery in July) to round out its starting pitching depth.

Once Santana and Hughes return, a Berrios-Santana-Odorizzi-Hughes-Gibson rotation in midseason should be enough to contend for the playoffs, aided by a bullpen greatly strengthened by general manager Thad Levine’s offseason moves.

MORE: Three things on the Twins’ to-do list

Minnesota’s offense will try to build upon breakout seasons from several of its young players. In addition to second baseman Brian Dozier’s 34-homer season, third baseman Miguel Sano — still just 24 years old — hit a career-high 28 home runs with 77 RBIs in just 484 plate appearances, but the beginning of his season is in doubt with an MLB assault investigation looming.

Left fielder Eddie Rosario, 26, hit .290 with a career-high 27 homers while slugging .507. Shortstop Jorge Polanco, just 24, came out of nowhere to drive in 74 runs, and 29-year-old Eduardo Escobar cracked 21 homers while filling in along the infield.

If Joe Mauer continues to hit over .300 with a .385 on base percentage and Minnesota sees progress from outfielders Byron Buxton, 24, and Max Kepler, 25, the Twins could even exceed their offensive success from last season.

Small-market teams have been making the playoffs more often lately, especially with the added wild-card spot in each league. But getting in year after year has proven more difficult. Minnesota has the 20th highest payroll in baseball, according to Sportrac, but with many offseason moves still yet to be made, the Twins will probably end up in the bottom 10.

Since the wild-card games were instituted in 2012, just two teams, the 2014-2015 Pirates and the 2012-2014 A’s, made the playoffs in consecutive years with a bottom-10 opening day payroll. One caveat, of course, is that some teams in that bottom tier raise payroll into the top 20 in July or August once contention is viewed as a possibility.  

Year Team Payroll rank
2017 Minnesota 22
2017 Arizona 26
2016 Cleveland 24
2015 N.Y. Mets 21
2015 Pittsburgh 25
2015 Houston 29
2014 Oakland 25
2014 Pittsburgh 27
2013 Cleveland 21
2013 Oakland 27
2013 Tampa Bay 28
2012 Oakland 29

Minnesota is poised to be the third team to make the playoffs in consecutive years with a lower-third opening payroll in the 10-team playoff era after making impressive signings for its bullpen and bolstering its rotation depth to go with an improving farm system. Their offseason won’t garner the hype of the bigger-market clubs, but the Twins improved their roster in just the right places as they look to made strides in a weakened AL Central.

New baby, encouraging finish to last season have Twins' Jorge Polanco feeling good in spring training

New baby, encouraging finish to last season have Twins' Jorge Polanco feeling good in spring training


– Jorge Polanco lost a family member with the death of his grandfather, Maximo, at 73 last June. The emotional impact was significant, as Jorge lived in San Pedro de Macoris, Dominican Republic, with Maximo for 16 years of his youth.

“My father was in New York and working there,’’ Polanco said. “My grandfather was like my father growing up.’’

Joe Mauer has earned every penny

Joe Mauer has earned every penny

The 2018 season is sure to feature some on-the-field milestones — Byron Buxton getting his first steal of third, Kyle Gibson convincing fans he’s finally “taken the next step” for the eighth and ninth times, and Brian Dozier maintaining a diabolical commitment to his hair.

What kind of product do you use?

Off the field, there is one milestone that, particularly to a certain sect of Twins fans, will mark 2018 as a year to remember: the expiration of Joe Mauer’s 8-year, $184-million contract.

This milestone — or millstone, depending on how one views Mauer’s extension — provides good an opportunity for me to examine Mauer’s legacy in a year with a lot riding on it.

Early last October, Hall of Fame expert Jay Jaffe weighed in on Mauer’s Hall of Fame chances and had this to say (note: WAR7 is a players’ Wins Above Replacement during his seven-year peak; JAWS is Jaffe’s rank of where a player would fit compared to Hall of Famers at the same defensive position):

There were a few replies to the assertion that Mauer has a good chance to be a Hall of Famer, the most salient of which belonged to our own RandBall’s Stu:

This response elicited a sad chuckle from this Mauer fan. It’s funny because it’s true. A significant portion of Twins fans view Mauer not as one of the greatest Twins of all time, which he unquestionably is; instead, to many in Twins Territory, Joe Mauer is a punchline.

Given the level of tomfoolery evinced by your average professional athlete, Joe Mauer is a saint. (Or a skim-swilling square, depending on one’s outlook.) Joe Mauer has been a consummate professional. He never badmouths his teammates, the fans — literally anyone. He has never been remotely close to any type of controversy or bad behavior. He won Halloween last year.

Well now that’s heartwarming.

Let me just scroll down a bit, maybe check out some comments. I love Twitter comments because they, too, are usually heartwarming. I’m assuming that maybe at least the first comment will be really sweet, who knows what shows up lower down, but that first comment, at least, will really encapsulate just how tender and beautiful this whole moment was…

Screenshot via Twitter

Let’s all thank Andrew Krauter for his immeasurable contributions to the public discourse. This is why we can’t have nice things, Andrew.

There are two inextricably linked reasons that fans like @Kraut23 act like colossal misanthropes when it comes to Joseph Patrick Mauer: The Injuries and The Contract. (Worst Seinfeld episodes EVER.) But it really starts and ends with The Contract because if the Twins hadn’t signed Mauer to an 8-year/$184 million contract on March 20, 2010, no one would blame Mauer for the injuries. It’s because he’s rich that people blame him for getting hurt and for not performing up to the big contract.

I know this is self-evident, but it’s worth pointing out every time this conversation comes up. (Apologies for the forthcoming Bolshevist diatribe.)

If we don’t play athletes, that money will go to owners. I, for one, do not want old, already-billionaires who inherited a company from their pappy getting more money than they’ve already not earned. Owners contribute nothing of value to an organization. Yes, they have the money, but the Twins could be a damn non-profit run by a public trust or owned by the fans.

I can’t speak for anyone else, but I personally would rather see my money go toward the players who actually do the playing.

Sports franchises have always been littered with weird, miserly, felonious, blood-sucking, racist, shady-ass, cretinous, Nazi-sympathizing, creepy owners. As Twins fans, a terrible owner literally founded our franchise. The only reason the Twins even moved to Minnesota was because Washington, D.C. was too black for former owner Calvin Griffith, who decided to let a room full of fans at the Waseca Lions Club know this in 1978.

If you’re unaware, read this from the Star Tribune’s Nick Coleman:

”There’s no damn place in the country worth moving to. They talk about New Orleans, but what’s wrong with that is…”

At that point, Griffith interrupted himself, lowered his voice and asked if there were any blacks around. After he looked around the room and assured himself that his audience was white, Griffith resumed his answer.

”I’ll tell you why we came to Minnesota,” he said. “It was when I found out you only had 15,000 blacks here. Black people don’t go to ball games, but they’ll fill up a rassling ring and put up such a chant it’ll scare you to death. It’s unbelievable. We came here because you’ve got good, hardworking, white people here.”

Thanks, I guess?

Griffith ultimately sold the Twins to Carl Pohlad because he didn’t like free agency’s impact on his bottom line or his ability to control “his” players.

Carl Pohlad certainly seemed a kindler, gentler fella than Griffith. But, like many billionaires, Pohlad amassed his fortune in a pretty grimy way. Pohlad first started accumulating his wealth by foreclosing on homes during the Great Depression, which he excelled at because of his “reputation as an emotionless guy who could efficiently collect loans,” as the Grand Forks Herald put it in his obituary.

Pohlad also accepted $250 million from Major League Baseball to allow the Twins to be contracted before Hennepin County Judge and borderline folk hero Harry Seymour Crump issued an injunction forcing the Twins to honor their lease at the Humbert H. Humphrey Metrodome. (As you may have noticed, the gambit worked. The Twins still exist.)

The Pohlads have also contributed money to charity and all that, though I tend to expect that from the 75th-richest family in the United States. They have ruthlessly maximized their earnings at every turn, whether it was coaxing $350 million of taxpayer money out of lawmakers to help build Target Field (the multi-billionaire Pohlads paid $195 million) or fighting an IRS estate-tax judgment to save $219.8 million. It is their prerogative — and, some would argue, duty — to ensure they retain as much of their vast fortune as possible. I do not hear people begrudging them for tirelessly maintaining their bottom line. It’s how rich people get and stay rich.

So why should Joe Mauer not be allowed the same? Why should he not ruthlessly maximize his worth when he’s the one actually playing the game? Why should Mauer not value himself accurately when he’s the one putting his body — and mind — on the line for a career that, if a player is lucky, lasts into his mid-to-late 30s?

If there’s a problem with Joe Mauer’s contract, it stems not from Mauer’s avarice but Major League Baseball’s horribly skewed salary and incentive structure. In January, during an offseason that had (and still has) been conspicuously absent of free-agent signings, Yahoo’s Jeff Passan published a massive story in which he asked a scary question about baseball’s economic structure: “Is the foundation of the sport, a structure in place since the advent of free agency in the 1970s, still viable?” Passan wrote. “Or is baseball’s economic system, its underpinning, broken?”

The problem at play is pretty simple: as front offices grow smarter, they’re less inclined to dole out massive free-agent contracts to players on the downswing of their careers. No one wants to sign the next Albert Pujols or Ryan Howard deal; and players — who (1) have their compensation capped by the draft or international market (2) make poverty-level wages in the minor leagues (3) and are stuck under team control and vastly underpaid during their prime years — want to recoup (at least some) of their mountain of lost earnings once they’ve reached free agency if they’re lucky enough to stick around through their team-control years.

In the last five years, baseball franchises have exploded in value — from a total of $18.1 billion to $46.1 billion, according to Passan. The Twins pulled in $253 million in revenue in 2017, and Forbes last valued the franchise at $1.03 billion in 2017 — a 3,219% return on the Pohlad’s $32 million initial investment. If you factor in inflation, $32 million in 1984 is (very roughly) $76.3 million in 2017 money, good for a 1,350% ROI. Still not too shabby. And if you really think about it, it’s an infinite ROI for the Pohlad brothers, who spent $0 on the Twins in 1984.

Major League Baseball is awash in money, and somebody has to gobble it up. But, for whatever reason, sports are oddly the only sector of American life where our raging capitalism boners disappear, replaced by a fervid desire to suppress salaries and impose odd market-killing restrictions that in other industries would be decried as a march toward Stalinist principles and signs of the looming nanny state.

America does love a fat cat, I suppose, and baseball owners certainly qualify. I’ll simply never understand why Twins fans would rather enrich Bill Pohlad than Joe Mauer. The Pohlads have money. No owner is cash-strapped, despite many of their consistent cries of “small-market team!” Because of Disney’s purchase of MLB Advanced Media, every baseball team will receive a check for more than $50 million this year simply for existing — on top of whatever revenues they’re already pulling in.

The Twins’ Opening Day payroll looks like it’ll come in around $113 million, or roughly what the 2011 payroll was, according to Cot’s. In 2011, that payroll ranked 9th in baseball. This year, it’ll be closer to 25th. Teams are richer and spending more money. The Twins are not.

With the explosion of revenue in MLB, it’s time we stop acting like paying Joe Mauer $23 million a season somehow prevents the team from adding other players via free agency. Yet, I’m sure all season we’ll hear how, now that Mauer’s contract is coming off the books, the Twins can finally splash the cash for 2019.

Passan hit on this issue on a recent episode of the Effectively Wild podcast. There was a telling moment about 50 minutes in where Passan had to stop himself from using the type of language so many of us have grown accustomed to. “The Red Sox may not be able to go out and — may not be willing to go out, rather,” he corrected himself. “I need to get that out of my lexicon, by the way. I find myself saying ‘may not be able to’ — no. They’re all able to. It’s a matter of willingness.”

Minnesota Twins v New York Yankees

Minnesota Twins v New York Yankees

Preparing to strike. Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

Joe Mauer was a worthwhile investment

Mauer serves as a very instructive example of how skewed the current salary system is in both underpaying elite players and perversely rewarding the decline years.

Since 2004, Joe Mauer has earned $195,025,000 in big-league salary. He’s owed $23 million more in 2018.

Conveniently for us, Fangraphs has been calculating the value of a win on the free-agent market since 2002, which allows them to then use a player’s WAR to calculate his value to his team.

Sure, the Twins have paid Mauer nearly $200 million in his career. That’s several truckloads of money. No argument here. But, according to Fangraphs’ data, Mauer has been worth $298.8 million to the franchise — an actually surplus value of $103.75 million. This factors in only on-field production, of course; there’s no consideration of Mauer’s ability to bring butts to the seats or sell shirseys.

I constructed a (rather crude) graph to show how Mauer’s value has basically had an inverse correlation to his paychecks over the course of his first 14 years with the Twins.

Graph by Louie. Data by Fangraphs/Baseball-Reference

This graph really sums up the problems in today’s baseball salaries: Mauer was hugely underpaid during his best years, and, for five of the seven seasons after signing his $184 million contract, a net-negative.

I’m not suggesting that Mauer “deserved” a $48 million-per-year contract in 2009, simply that he was worth that to the Twins while getting paid just $10.5 million. And, yes, I know “just $10.5 million” is an absurd phrase, and “they’re playing a kids’ game,” all the other old saws, etc. etc. But this is not a “kids’ game.” It is a near-trillion dollar industry where those who actually create the product we love are significantly underpaid to ensure more money returns to billionaire owners. Do not shed a tear for the Pohlads. They’ll be just fine.

MLB 6-12-05: Minnesota Twins at LA Dodgers

MLB 6-12-05: Minnesota Twins at LA Dodgers

Watch Joe run. Photo by John Cordes/Sporting News via Getty Images

A victim of poor timing

More than anything, the perception of Mauer’s contract soured so immediately because of injury. Again, The Contract and The Injuries are inseparable. Mauer signed his deal right before the 2010 season, in which he hit .327/.402/.469 and won his third consecutive Gold Glove and Silver Slugger at the catcher position. So far, so good!

But Mauer’s contract didn’t kick in until the 2011 season. Early in the 2011 season, Mauer went down with a mysterious malady theretofore unknown to Twins fans (and most anybody, I’d guess) called “bilateral leg weakness.” Those three words remain a punchline in Minnesota sports because they have the misfortune of being both made-up sounding and not-that-painful sounding. The diagnosis confirmed a lot of the simmering biases and misconceptions that many Twins fans harbored — that Mauer was weak, lazy, noncompetitive, and that, worst of all, he didn’t really care about the team.

The odd injury and the contract spurred a raft of hot takes that hammered away at this refrain. The funniest take, in retrospect, was Jim Souhan excoriating Mauer for not volunteering to play first base while Justin Morneau was hurt. (In classic Souhanian fashion, the column was titled “Perhaps it’s time to ask Joe for some millions back.”)

You may recall this was after Jose Mijares, of all people, had the temerity to question Mauer’s pitch-calling. Instead of pointing out that Mijares was crap — he was two months into a season that he finished with 30 walks, 30 strikeouts and a 4.88 FIP — and not exactly a role model of dedication, Souhan had this takeaway: “[Mauer] got called out by a lefthanded middle reliever over his pitch calls, a sure sign that Mauer is less popular in the clubhouse than the IRS. Can you imagine Jose Mijares jabbing Mauer if Mauer’s average were .340 and he was playing every day?”

So, as far as I can tell, the logic here was that if Mauer, one of the best hitters in the history of baseball, was hitting better through the comically small sample size of 18 games after a debilitating injury, then a Twins afterthought wouldn’t have complained about getting shelled? If Mijares truly didn’t respect Mauer, wouldn’t he just have shook him off? Was that too hard on Mijares’ neck? Sorry, I’m now dissecting terrible old Souhan columns, a fool’s errand if ever there was one.

Mauer certainly struggled in 2011, though he did end the season with an OPS+ of 102, just above league average. The year after signing his record-breaking contract, Mauer’s production cost the Twins $13.5 million in value lost, according to Fangraphs’ calculations. Of course, if one were sensible and took the long view of the situation, you’d recognize that before his contract Mauer had accrued nearly $148 million in surplus value for his hometown team. So, after his disappointing 2011 season, Mauer had still put the Twins $134.48 million in the black.

Even with his new $23 million/year deal, in 2012 and 2013 Mauer provided Minnesota with $22 million in surplus value.

If 2011 was the season in which Twins fans really began to sour on Mauer, 2013 was the year when things really went downhill, all because of the August 19, 2013 concussion that knocked Mauer out for the season and off the catcher position for good.

Here’s a rather unsavory thought experiment that I think is useful: What if, instead of sustaining another less-understood injury (concussions), on August 13, 2013, Joe had contracted ALS like Lou Gehrig? Or an occlusion of the retinal blood vessel, leaving him blind in one eye like Kirby Puckett? At that point, Mauer had batted .323/.405/.468 with an 11.2% strikeout rate and a 12.2% walk rate for his career, as Aaron Gleeman points out in a terrific article I refer to fairly frequently.

In this terrible alternative world, Mauer would have ended his 10-year career as a three-time batting champion, a five-time All-Star, a five-time Silver Slugger, a three-time Gold Glove-winner, and an American League MVP — all from the most difficult, demanding defensive position. Mauer had produced the fifth-most Wins Above Replacement of any catcher through an age-30 season (Mauer turned 30 two weeks into the 2013 season), behind only Johnny Bench, Gary Carter, Ivan Rodriguez, and Ted Simmons — four of whom are Hall of Famers, and one, Simmons, who certainly could be.

It’s impossible to know how Mauer would have aged without his numerous concussions. Perhaps his career would look just like it does today. As they say, age is undefeated.

But as macabre as it is to imagine, if Mauer had been struck down by a career-ending injury or disease, I don’t think there’s any argument: he would have been a first-ballot Hall of Famer. Instead, he was struck down by a brain injury that scientists still don’t fully understand, let alone fans. It’s a shadow injury, a specter that hangs over a player who may look similar to his former self but isn’t quite the same — like the seventh photocopy of a piece of paper, where the gist remains but the edges have faded and are harder and harder to recognize as the original you remember.

Joe Mauer continues to play as much as he can, continues to show up and do his best, and, yes, continues to collect his paycheck. But he’s not the same. His vision gets blurry, his hand-eye coordination has diminished — the latter the cruelest joke on a player who relied so heavily on his quick reactions to succeed. I know Joe Mauer will never go hungry; he lives a blessed life. But his story is also a tragic one, filled with possibilities of what could have been and uncertainties about what his life will look like as his body and, most frighteningly, his brain, age. It’s not just a child’s game.

More than anything, I hope that we can look at Mauer not for what he isn’t but for what he is: a hometown boy who made good to become one of the best Twins, — and best baseball players — we’ll ever see.

For all he’s given this team, we owe him that.